Days Gone By - stories from the past

There were no churches in old St. Stephens

Reminiscences of Old St. Stephens Part II Schools and Indians

NOTE: This speech was made in 1899 and some language would be offensive today. It has been transcribed as written)

(Read at the Centennial Celebration, May 6, 1899. It was published in four installments in the Washington County News, St. Stephens, May 25, and June 1, 8, and 15, 1899.

By Miss Mary Welsh of Shuqualak, Miss)i


Choctaw Chief Pushmataha

Choctaw Chief Pushmataha

No churches in early St. Stephens

In the history of any place next in importance to churches come school interests. There were no churches in St. Stephens, as we have seen; and of its one-time academyii and newspaperiii I know nothing. The first teacher of whom I know anything was Mr. D. H. Mayhew a native of Massachusetts, who died Sept. 7, 1822, aged 40 years, and is buried at St. Stephens. I never knew whether he had a family or not.

Pushmataha wanted to educate his son Mingo

My mother was one of his pupils and she cherished a respectful and loving memory of him as long as she lived. She often related to her children incidents of her school life, and one of them is so associated with the history of St. Stephens as to deserve a place here. The citizens, grateful for the friendly services of Pushmataha, the Choctaw chief, during the Creek war, thought the best return they could make would be to educate his son Mingo. The old chief was pleased, so Mingo was duly entered as a pupil in Mr.. Mayhew’s school. Ordinarily he was a pretty fair pupil; but and unfortunately for the plan of the whites large numbers of Indians, the friendly, inoffensive Choctaws, remained in the country.

Indian baths in St. Stephens (photographer Carol Highsmith - Library of Congress)Indian baths at Old St. Stephens Park, St. Stephens, Alabama (photographed by Carol Highsmith, Library of Congress)

Mingo returned to his tribe

Often numbers of them came to town, camped in the outskirts and made the whole place lively by their nightly carousing. This was too much for the wild Indian boy to withstand. He would slip out after dark and spend night after night in the wild orgies of his companions, and of course through the day, although dutifully in the school room, was too dull for study. Friendly remonstrance, judicious counsel, even punishment availed but little, and only for the time of the absence of the Indians. Every new camp was an occasion for Mingo to break the bonds of attempted civilization. Finally Mr. Mayhew said, “it is useless; Indian will be Indian,” and gave it up as an impossible job. Mingo returned to his tribe, and his faithful teacher sleeps in old St. Stephens cemetery.

First teacher Charles L. S. Jones

My first teacher was Charles L. S. Jones who taught during the years 1828, 1829, and 1830. He had a wife, and some children too small for school. His later career I know nothing of. I cannot characterize him better than by referring to the description of an old time “dominie” in Sir Walter Scott’s novels. He was a kindly man as I remember him; and as I remember ourselves he had a wild set under his care. He was a learned man for that day and time, but little did we youngsters reck of his learning, though in after years I often recalled with pride that my first teacher translated a volume of Latin poetry into English. We had a copy of that work till 1880 when it was unfortunately destroyed.

Studied out loud if we chose

We studied “out loud” if we chose, sat on the benches or on desks at will, or the “big boys” took their books and slates out under the trees. The text books that we “floundered through” a modern pupil would throw down in angry disgust. “Lindley Murray’s” grammar, “Greenlee’s” or “Greenleaf’s” geography, &c, &c.

And he would scorn our school furniture; desks built around the room against the wall, backless benches, pencils made of bullets run together and beaten into proper shape, copy-books made of sheets of unruled paper stitched together and ruled as we could get it done. The boys who were fortunate enough to own these lead pencils performed a good work of love in ruling books for the unskilled. Pens of quills plucked from the geese at home were made and mended by the master. But we managed to have a great deal of fun with it all.

Plenty of attractions lured us away from school

We had two good honest hours at noon, and recess as often as we could obtain permission or slip out unawares. There were plenty of attractions to lure us out of doors and keep us out as long as we dared. Ah! it was a wild, rolicsome, childishly happy time, but not wasted; we did learn something and that thoroughly.

Besides, our unrestrained gambols in God’s free air and sunshine and pure water, the best tonics in the world, built up our muscular systems, and gathered up a fund of good spirits for the requirements of future years; and some of us have needed the full supply in the subsequent battle of life. Oh, ye fathers and mothers! let your children be children while they may. Cares and anxiety come soon enough, and when they come they remain throughout the journey of life.

Both husband and wife taught school

The next school commenced about 1831, and was taught by Mr. and Mrs. James Duncan English people. They taught some time prior to this in Jackson, Ala., and came to St. Stephens about 1830. Duncan, as I learned many years afterwards, was an assumed name. Both husband and wife taught school, and the madam taught various kinds of needle-work in addition. Their eldest daughter taught music and according to the system then in vogue, which was almost a snail’s pace compared to the present system.

Here we had pretty much the same text books as in the Jones’ school; the same desks against the wall, backless benches, homemade pencils, &c. The old gentleman brought some steel pens, till then unknown in these parts, and tried to introduce them, perhaps to spare himself some work. But the effort proved to be premature; his patrons mostly believed in encouraging home industry; so we still “run down” the geese, plucked the quills and carried them to him to make into pens.

Discipline was more strict

Neither the system nor the discipline of this school was anything like we had been accustomed to; we were not the “happy-go-lucky” set we had been formerly. Nevertheless we managed to extract a good deal of enjoyment from the untoward circumstances.

Boarders were in this school

They lived and taught in a large building on the principal street. The second and third stories were occupied by the family and their boarders; there were boarders in this school. The whole lower floor was divided into two long, large rooms. One of them was used for a dining-room, the other, the school room, had been, in the early times, the store of Messrs. Coolidge & Bright.iv Shelves were still along the walls, and on a large beam running through the center, supported by two or three pillars, was the name of the firm in gilt letters. The old house survived till the removal of the town.

Duncan was not their real name

This school was the last one in old St. Stephens. After the death of the father and mother, the two daughters went to England, where the eldest, Miss Charlotte, received some entailed property. They returned to Alabama under the name Pettit and taught near Warsaw several years, about 1847. They explained that their father assumed the name of Duncan in consequence of something that occurred in the British navy, or merchant service, in which he was an officer, that necessitated his remaining incognito for a time; and that necessity lasted as long as he did. A son, James Petitt went to Arkansas, and Miss Mary Pettit married a Mr. Marr in that State.

Incident at the school regarding race

Apropos of the religious sentiment of St. Stephens at the time, an incident in which he was prime actor will serve to show his standing in that respect. He had courteously given permission to the Baptist preacher, Rev. William Shoemaker to preach in his school room. After a few services, one Sunday morning the minister gave an opportunity for any one who might wish to join the church. Two colored women presented themselves. Immediately Mr. and Mrs. Duncan arose, gathered up all the pupils who were present, day pupils as well as boarders, marched us out and upstairs regardless of the presence of several of our parents. He peremptorily forbade any more preaching under his roof; said a negro had no more soul than a monkey, and no preacher who treated them as responsible beings should have the use of his house. After that Mr. S. preached a few times in Grandmother Gordy’s hall. That ended religious services in old St. Stephens, as far as I know.

Family is Irish

The Welsh family is Irish, coming from Penn. to Buncombe Co., N. C and thence to St. Stephens. The Gordys are of French origin, and came from Delaware to Clinton Co., Ga. In the thirties Miss Welsh’s immediate family removed to Mississippi. Her “Reminiscences” give the facts of her early life. She has been a professional teacher, newspaper writer, and Assistant Superintendent of the Confederate Orphans’ Home at Lauderdale Springs, Miss. After a long life of useful labor and effort, she now lives quietly at her home full of pleasing memories of men and things of “ye olden time” in the first settled regions of the State.

iMiss Mary Welsh, daughter of Capt. George Welsh (son of Wm. Welsh and Jane Thompson) and his wife, Sally Gordy (daughter of Elijah Gordy and Tabitha Melson), was born at St. Stephens, Nov. 9, 1823. The Welsh family is Irish, coming from Penn. to Buncombe Co., N. C and thence to St. Stephens. The Gordys are of French origin, and came from Delaware to Clinton Co., Ga. In the thirties Miss Welsh’s immediate family removed to Mississippi. Her “Reminiscences” give the facts of her early life. She has been a professional teacher, newspaper writer, and Assistant Superintendent of the Confederate Orphans’ Home at Lauderdale Springs, Miss. After a long life of useful labor and effort, she now lives quietly at her home full of pleasing memories of men and things of “ye olden time” in the first settled regions of the State.

iiAs early as Dec. 17, 1811, the Territorial Legislature had incorporated “Washington Academy,” at St. Stephens, in Washington Co. Other Acts relating thereto were passed Nov. 25, 1812, and Dec. 24, 1814. On Feb. 7, 1818, St. Stephens Academy was incorporated. Mr. Mayhew was one of the trustees named for the latter. Its supporters were the leading men of the community.—Toulmin’s Laws of Ala. (1823), pp. 540-3. The National Intelligencer, Sept. 5, 1816. states that the paper at St. Stephens M. T., on Aug. 9, 1816, printed an account of an examination and exhibition at the St. Stephens Academy on Friday and Saturday last, highly honorable to the students and creditable to Mr. Mayhew, the instructor. It copies the following language and commends it:

“We hail with pleasure, the establishment of a literary institution so promising in this country, lately a wilderness, the haunt of savages, where nought but ignorance and barbarity abounded. It is worthy of remark, that amongst upwards of seventy scholars from different parts of the county, and some from the States, there is not a single instance of sickness.”

iiiThe Halcyon, begun in the spring of 1815 by Thomas Eastin, Esq. See Editorial Notes appended to Justus Wyman’s “Sketch,” supra.

iv“This was an old firm of merchants, composed of Elias Coolidge and Henry Bright, which was in business in the town in 1818.—Minor’s (Ala.) Report, pp. 11, 103. Descendants of the Coolidge family live in Kemper Co., Miss

Discordance: The Cottinghams (Volume 1) – A novel inspired by the experiences of the Cottingham family who immigrated from the Eastern Shore of Virginia to Alabama

Buy Now
See larger image

Additional Images:Img - 1508837457
Img - 1508837457

Discordance: The Cottinghams (Volume 1) (Paperback)

By (author):  Causey, Donna R

List Price: $14.97
New From: $14.97 In Stock
buy now

About Donna R Causey

Donna R. Causey, resident of Alabama, was a teacher in the public school system for twenty years. When she retired, Donna found time to focus on her lifetime passion for historical writing. She developed the websites www.alabamapioneers and All her books can be purchased at and Barnes & Noble. She has authored numerous genealogy books. RIBBON OF LOVE: A Novel Of Colonial America (TAPESTRY OF LOVE) is her first novel in the Tapestry of Love about her family where she uses actual characters, facts, dates and places to create a story about life as it might have happened in colonial Virginia. Faith and Courage: Tapestry of Love (Volume 2) is the second book and the third FreeHearts: A Novel of Colonial America (Book 3 in the Tapestry of Love Series) Discordance: The Cottinghams (Volume 1) is the continuation of the story. . For a complete list of books, visit Donna R Causey

Liked it? Take a second to support Alabama Pioneers on Patreon!


  1. Kimberley Jackson Curry

  2. Jean Kathleen Sanders Parnell

  3. It’s funny, but I know or have known someone in Alabama named Pettit (relative), Gordy (schoolmate) and Cottingham (my kg teacher).

    1. I believe many Alabamians will find we are more connected and even related than we realize.

  4. […] Native Americans found by the French in Washington County resided on the west bank of the Tombigbee and were called […]

  5. Beautiful park and love it!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.