Days Gone By - stories from the past

LIKE GRANDMA USE TO MAKE – Old homemade Eggnog recipes for the holidays


Old homemade Eggnog Recipes for the holidays

EGGNOG (no-alcohol) (1910s)

  • 4 c. (1 Qt.) milk
  • 2-4 eggs
  • 2 t. vanilla or 4 T. orange juice or other flavoring
  • 1/3 t. nutmeg – used it desired with vanilla
  • 4 T. to 6 T. sugar (If maple flavoring is desired, use half maple and half granulated sugar)

Mix ½ c. milk, cracked ice, sugar, and eggs. Stir, but do not beat, until thoroughly mixed. Add remaining milk, more cracked ice, and flavoring. Beat with dover beater (mechanical egg beater) and serve.

Rotary Egg beater

EGGNOG (with alcohol) (1980s)

  • 1-1/2 doz. eggs
  • 1-1/2 cups sugar
  • 1 qt. bourbon whiskey
  • 2 qt. whipping cream
  • 1 qt. milk
  • Nutmeg

Separate eggs and put whites aside. Beat yolks until light, about 30 minutes with hand mixer (not electric) Gradually beat in one cup of sugar. Add liquor very slowly while beating yolks. Beat in quart of milk gradually. Beat egg whites until stiff, then gradually add remaining sugar. Fold mixture gently into the whipped cream and then into beaten egg whites. Pour into punch bowl and sprinkle with nutmeg.

Christmas in the South Eggnog party ca. 1870 drawn by W. L. Sheppard (Library of Congress)

COCOA EGGNOG (no alcohol) (1930s)

  • 1 egg white
  • 1 teaspoon sugar
  • 1 teaspoon cocoa
  • ¼ cup top milk (chilled)
  • ½ vanilla
  • Few grains salt

Sift sugar cocoa and salt together. Beat egg white stiffly. Gradually add sugar, cocoa and salt mixture to the beaten egg whites and beat thoroughly. Add milk, flavoring and beat well with rotary beater (not electric)

Fancy Punchbowl – .S.S. Kentucky’s punch bowl ca. 1900 Edward Hart photographer (Detroit Publishing Company, Library of Congress)

EGGNOG (with alcohol)(1940s)

For each serving:

  • 1 egg
  • 1 T bourbon
  • 1 T sugar
  • 1 scoop vanilla ice cream

Separate egg and beat egg whites until very stiff while gradually adding sugar. Beat yolks of eggs with bourbon. Put scoop of ice cream in punch cup. Fold together egg mixtures and fill up the remainder of the punch cup. Top with whipped cream, sprinkle nutmeg over top of whipped cream and place a cherry on top.

Man and woman at punch bowl ca. 1935 (Harris and Ewing, Library of Congress)

EGGNOG (with alcohol)(1960s)

  • 12 Eggs
  • 12 tablespoons sugar
  • 1-1/2 cups Bourbon
  • ½ cup Jamaican rum
  • 1 pint whipping cream

Beat eggs thoroughly, gradually adding sugar and beat until sugar is dissolved and not grainy. Pour liquor in very slowly so as to cook eggs. Beat whites stiff – fold into above mixture. Whip cream stiff and fold all but a small amount into egg mixture – float the balance on top of the eggnog and sprinkle with nutmeg. Serves 12.

EGGNOG CHARLOTTE (with alcohol)(1960s)

  • 1 quart whipping cream
  • 3 egg yolks, beaten
  • 1 cup sugar
  • 1 envelope gelatin, softened in cold water
  • ½ cup brandy
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla

Add brandy to yolk and sugar mixture. Add dissolved gelatin, then fold in 3 egg whites stiffly beaten and whipped cream. Add vanilla.

Discordance: The Cottinghams Inspired by true events and the Cottingham family that resided in 17th century Somerset, Maryland, and Delaware, colonial America comes alive with pirate attacks, religious discord, and governmental disagreements in the pre-Revolutionary War days of America.

Discordance: The Cottinghams (Volume 1) (Paperback)

By (author):  Donna R Causey
List Price:$9.77 USD
New From:$9.77 USD In Stock
buy now

About Donna R Causey

Donna R. Causey, resident of Alabama, was a teacher in the public school system for twenty years. When she retired, Donna found time to focus on her lifetime passion for historical writing. She developed the websites www.alabamapioneers and All her books can be purchased at and Barnes & Noble. She has authored numerous genealogy books. RIBBON OF LOVE: A Novel Of Colonial America (TAPESTRY OF LOVE) is her first novel in the Tapestry of Love about her family where she uses actual characters, facts, dates and places to create a story about life as it might have happened in colonial Virginia. Faith and Courage: Tapestry of Love (Volume 2) is the second book and the third FreeHearts: A Novel of Colonial America (Book 3 in the Tapestry of Love Series) Discordance: The Cottinghams (Volume 1) is the continuation of the story. . For a complete list of books, visit Donna R Causey

Liked it? Take a second to support Alabama Pioneers on Patreon!

One comment

  1. Nan Taylor McLeod

    Orange juice ? No thank you

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.